Best dumpster rental companies in
Staten Island, New York.
The 4 highest-rated dumpster rental companies in Staten Island, ranked by our DCS Score. Average rating: 4.7 stars across 195 reviews.
How We Rank: The DCS Score
Every hauler is scored 0–100 using five weighted criteria. No pay-to-play, no broker bias — just data.
Unlock the lowest price
We found Perciballi Container Service as the top-rated, best-value hauler in Staten Island. Enter your email to see their pricing and exclusive deals.
Free • No spam • Unsubscribe anytime
22 Van St, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA
97 Lake Ave, Staten Island, NY 10303
25 Van St, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA
2351 Richmond Ter, Staten Island, NY 10302
What makes a dumpster company “best”?
Verified review volume
A company with 200+ Google reviews is far more trustworthy than one with 8. In Staten Island, we weight review count heavily because it's the hardest metric to fake.
Consistently high ratings
A 4.8-star average means nothing if the last 10 reviews are all 1-star. We measure rating consistency over time, not just the headline number.
Local presence, not a broker
The best haulers in Staten Island own their own trucks and containers. Brokers subcontract delivery and add $50-$150 in middleman fees you'll never see itemized.
Transparent pricing
Top-rated companies publish their prices or give clear quotes with weight limits, rental periods, and overage fees spelled out upfront. No surprise charges on pickup day.
Complete business data
A legitimate dumpster company has a local phone number, a physical address, a website, and listed business hours. Missing data is a red flag.
Red flags to watch for
- Zero or very few reviewsLegitimate haulers who've been operating for more than a year should have at least a dozen Google reviews. No reviews often means a brand-new shell company or a broker masking their identity.
- Out-of-state phone numberIf you're renting in Staten Island but the phone number has a different state's area code, you're likely calling a national broker's call center, not a local operator.
- No website or a generic landing pageA real dumpster company invests in their web presence. A single-page site with no address, no photos of their equipment, and no pricing info is a red flag.
- Broker language ("we connect you with...")Phrases like "nationwide network," "we partner with local haulers," or "get connected" mean you're talking to a middleman, not the company that will deliver your dumpster.
- No weight ticket or tonnage estimateReputable haulers provide weight tickets after pickup and give you clear tonnage limits upfront. Companies that dodge weight questions often hit you with surprise overage fees.
Compare prices in Staten Island
See side-by-side pricing for 10, 20, 30, and 40 yard dumpsters from Staten Island haulers. Average costs, weight limits, and rental periods.
Best dumpster rentals nearby
Frequently asked questions
How do I choose the best dumpster rental company in Staten Island?
Look for companies with high Google ratings (4.5+), a large number of verified reviews, transparent pricing with no hidden fees, and local phone numbers. Our DCS Score combines all of these factors into a single 0–100 ranking so you can compare Staten Island haulers at a glance.
What is the DCS Score and how is it calculated?
The DCS (Dumpster Comparison Score) is our proprietary 0–100 rating that evaluates dumpster rental companies across five weighted criteria: Rating Quality (25 points), Review Volume (25 points), Consistency (15 points), Trust Signals (20 points), and Data Completeness (15 points). A higher score means more trustworthy, better-reviewed service.
Should I use a local hauler or a national broker in Staten Island, New York?
Local haulers in Staten Islandalmost always offer better pricing and service than national brokers. Brokers add a middleman markup of $50–$150 and have less control over delivery timing and customer service. Every company ranked on this page operates directly in Staten Island— we exclude brokers from our “best” rankings.
What customers are saying
“Easily the most pleasure I have had ever with any company I have dealt with before. Prices was unbeatable, the drop off and pick up was right on time and the overall attention to detail was unreal. A+++++ experience! Can’t thank you all enough!”
Steven Shinkar“We hired Island Redi-Mix for our new house/construction. They are great. Kiro was so quick and professional responding to all the requests and paperwork required. Great customer service and quality work. Thank You!”
E Q